Find your perfect match

We'll match you with the perfect product to maximize pleasure, performance and satisfaction

Let's do this!
PREMIUM PLEASURE PRODUCTS · FOR MEN

Penile Traction Device vs Penis Pump: Which Option is Best?

7 min read
Penile Traction Device vs Penis Pump: Which Option is Best?

If you're thinking about experimenting with penis extenders, you'll have almost certainly seen both penile traction devices and penis pumps either advertised or discussed online. The trouble is, the marketing hype for each kind of device can be extremely compelling - leaving you wondering what the truth is and which is actually the best option.

In this article, we'll examine why the answer you're looking for might actually be "both." We'll explain the differences between these devices and why those differences can often complement each other, leading to a better chance of long-lasting gains. Don't worry though, if you're just looking for one or the other, we'll give you all the info you need to make the right choice too.

At a Glance

  • Traction Devices offer permanent size gains through consistent, long-term use by stretching the penile tissue. They are ideal for those seeking gradual and lasting growth and can also address conditions like Peyronie’s disease (penile curvature).

  • Penis Pumps provide temporary gains in size by enhancing blood flow to the penis, useful for erectile dysfunction or short-term enlargement before sexual activity. While not proven for permanent growth, consistent use may yield long-term improvements.

  • Combined Use of both devices could optimize results. Traction devices promote tissue growth, while pumps enhance blood flow. They potentially complement each other by enhancing blood flow, speeding up healing, and maintaining elasticity.

  • Choosing One: Traction devices are best for long-term, permanent growth, while pumps suit those looking for immediate, short-term enhancements with potential gradual improvements.

Traction Device and Penis Pumps: Similarities and Differences

Traction Device 

  • Supports penile tissue development
  • Worn for several hours daily
  • Uses a stretching force on the penis
  • Proven to offer permanent size gains

Penis Pumps 

  • Mostly used for blood flow and blood vessel enhancement
  • Works very quickly to help create an erection
  • Uses negative air pressure to draw blood into the penis
  • Medically recommended for erectile dysfunction
  • Proven to offer temporary length/girth gains

Shared Features 

  • Safe, non-invasive enhancement method
  • Discreet at-home device
  • Enhance size and quality of erections
  • Can help to treat penile curvature/Peyronie’s disease
  • Cost-effective compared to surgery


While vacuum erection devices and penile traction devices are both designed to increase penis size in one way or another, they do have differences. We've put this info together into a handy diagram so you can see how the devices compare at a glance:

Venn Diagram of the Traction Device and Penis Pumps Similarities and Differences

    Penile Traction Device vs Penis Pump

    Unfortunately, there are a lot of penis enlargement myths and misconceptions. Device marketing sometimes adds to this - especially when phrases like "Instant lasting gains!" or "Adds X inches!" are used. Terms like these are not a true representation of how a traction device or a vacuum constriction device actually works.

    As such, it's useful to understand the reality of these devices to see how what they really do, the kind of routine needed for each, and which is going to be the best solution for you:

    How Do Traction Devices Contribute to Size Gains?

    Penile traction devices work by applying a constant, gentle stretch to the penis over a prolonged period. This technique, called "tissue expansion," is based on the body’s natural response to consistent pressure.

    When tissues are stretched, tiny microtears occur in the cells. As part of the body’s natural healing process, these microtears are repaired, leading to the formation of new tissue. Over time, this kind of traction routine can result in an increase in both length and girth.

    Penile traction devices work by applying a constant, gentle stretch to the penis over a prolonged period.

    It's useful to think of it like how muscle grows through exercise: when you lift weights, your muscles experience small tears, and when they heal, they grow bigger. In the case of penile traction, it’s a very similar kind of tissue growth.

    While penis surgery had previously been considered the only effective method of increasing penis size - leading Urology experts who have been at the center of therapeutic advances in the use of traction now publicly state that traction should be the first method offered for men who want to increase their size.

    How to Penis Pumps Contribute to Size Gains?

    A penis pump - sometimes referred to medically as a "vacuum erection device" - works by creating a vacuum around the penis, drawing blood into the erectile tissues, which causes them to expand. This swelling results in a temporary increase in penile length and girth, often lasting for a few hours, making pumps a popular choice for those looking to enhance their size before sexual activity. However, some men use pumps regularly in the hopes of achieving longer-term size gains.

    While there isn’t strong scientific evidence to support permanent size increases from penis pumps, anecdotal reports from online communities suggest otherwise. Many men claim that consistent pumping over months or even years can lead to gradual, permanent growth. They liken the process to stretching a muscle — regular expansion of the tissue may encourage it to grow over time.

    For those aiming to see lasting changes, consistent and careful use of the pump over a prolonged period is key. 

    In addition to potential size changes, regular use of a penis pump may improve blood flow and overall vascular health, leading to fuller erections. While this doesn't necessarily mean permanent gains, some men feel that improved circulation enhances overall erectile function - and can make their erections look thicker and more engorged - even when not using the pump.

    For those aiming to see lasting changes, consistent and careful use of the pump over a prolonged period is key. Many men also combine pumping with other methods, like manual exercises, to enhance their results, believing that this combination makes the process more effective.

    Why is it a Good Idea to Use Traction and Pumping Together? (What Science and Users Say)

    According to the tens of thousands of men who are actively exploring penis extenders - using a combination of both penile traction devices and pumps is likely to offer complementary benefits, especially when the goal is long-term size gains.

    As you now know, traction devices work by slowly stretching the penile tissue over time, encouraging the formation of new cells through a process known as tissue expansion. On the other hand, pumps enhance blood flow - which may then help nourish the newly stretched tissue with essential nutrients and oxygen, giving it the best environment for healthy growth and recovery.

    Let's break down why the combination of these approaches appears particularly effective:

    1: Enhancing Blood Flow for Tissue Health

    Traction alone can stretch and expand tissue - but blood flow is essential for tissue to heal and develop properly.

    Pumping can temporarily increase oxygen-rich blood flow so the stretched areas are well nourished. This can aid the healing process, speed up recovery after traction, remove waste cells from the area, and optimize the environment for new tissue to form.

    2: "Synergistic" Growth

    Traction devices promote growth through microtears, while pumps can expand the erectile tissue to its maximum capacity in the short term.

    This can work together to reinforce tissue expansion on two fronts - traction slowly elongates the tissue, then pumping keeps the tissue elastic and well vascularized.

    3: Countless Positive User Reports

    Many men in online communities believe that using both techniques together leads to better results than using either one alone. According to anecdotal reports, regular pumping helps maintain the elasticity of tissues stretched by traction, while the traction device ensures that the growth remains steady and long-term.

    Users often describe this combination as a way to "train" the penis to adapt to both sustained stretching and short-term expansion.

    Again, while there hasn't been a lot of scientific research into this area - users consider it a tried-and-tested essential part of successful routines.

    4: Maintaining Long-Term Gains

    Many users note that regular pumping, even after long periods of traction use, helps "lock in" the gains long-term - preventing any "shrinkage" when a regular traction routine is discontinued.

    Since pumping increases blood flow and encourages maximum expansion, it stands to reason that it helps maintain the elasticity and pliability of the newly grown tissue, keeping it healthy and ensuring that the gains remain permanent.

    What if You Can Only Choose One Device?

    While pumping and traction are the go-to combo for people who are rigorous in their pursuit of more size, we fully appreciate there's every possibility that your budget won't allow for two devices focused on penile stretching - so what should you do if you can only justify one purchase?

    Here, we've looked at some factors that will help steer you toward the right single purchase for you:

    WHEN TO CHOOSE A TRACTION DEVICE WHEN TO CHOOSE A PENIS PUMP
    You’re looking for long-term, gradual gains over time.
      You want immediate, temporary gains in size, especially before sex.
        You want a device that can be worn under clothing all day.
          You want to improve erection quality and blood flow, maybe to address erectile dysfunction.
            You’re patient and willing to commit to regular, long-term use (several hours a day) for several months.
              You prefer shorter, daily or weekly sessions rather than wearing a device for hours.
                You’re targeting specific issues like curvature correction (e.g. Peyronie’s disease).
                  You want a device that offers size enhancement and improved circulation in the short term.
                    You want a device with scientific backing for tissue expansion through stretching.
                      You’re more focused on girth than length or want a balance of both.
                        You’re okay with slower results but want permanent gains in length.
                          You like temporary gains that may translate into longer-term improvements with consistent use.

                              How to Find the Right Performance Enhancement Tool for You

                              Penile Traction Therapy vs Vacuum Pump Therapy: A Summary

                              Hopefully, this article sheds some light on the merits of combining penis growth techniques - as well as the individual benefits of pumps and traction devices.

                              Traction therapy has a medically proven place in the penis enlargement world - and, while not currently medically proven, penis pumps have an equal place among the tens of thousands of men who are looking to improve their length and girth.

                              The devices work in different ways - and although both are widely thought to offer their own unique benefits, the most significant benefits come when people use them together as part of a structured and consistent routine. By increasing the muscle tissue in your penis with a traction device and then supporting blood flow to that tissue with a vacuum device, you're not only approaching the problem with two unique solutions - the two devices will also likely complement each other, maximizing gains.

                              Our Commitment to Precision: The Intersection of our blog information and our product design methodologies

                              Our commitment to precision intersects with the methodologies we use for providing accurate information on our blog and designing and manufacturing our products:

                              • We have a human-centered approach both for our product design and information on the site.
                              • We base our processes on real feedback, and we're driven by sex welfare and optimal performance.
                              • We're thorough and passionate about helping men achieve their best.
                              • We follow complex and proven processes, whether for designing products or producing informative content on our blog.
                              • We rely on experts in their field to make sure every aspect of our production is bulletproof.
                              Learn more about our selection process

                              L·Y·N·K

                              ON SALE